Independent research on 275 HR & workforce products. Facts checked against vendors’ official documentation.

We may earn a referral fee. We may earn a referral feeHow we make money

Paychex PEO

Best Paychex PEO Alternatives

10 products that do the same job as Paychex PEO, matched to the reason you might switch, with similarity scores and how each one is priced.

By LeadChange Research TeamUpdated Based on 33 sources, most recently checked

LeadChange may earn a fee when you request pricing through our site or follow a sponsored link. Rankings never depend on whether a vendor pays us.We may earn a fee.

Paychex PEO alternatives, closest first

  1. ADP TotalSourceSimilarity 83
  2. Abel HRSimilarity 75
  3. DecisionHRSimilarity 75

Alternatives by reason for switching

  • Published price

    Justworks

    $1,975 a month at 25 employees; Paychex PEO does not publish comparable prices.

    $79/employee/mo (PEO Basic plan)1

  • Published pricing

    Deel

    Highest-scoring alternative that publishes its prices (5.4/10).

    Published2

  • Built for larger companies

    Amplify HR

    Serves enterprise companies; Paychex PEO does not list enterprise among the sizes it serves.

    Small businesses, mid-market companies, enterprises3

  • Month-to-month terms

    CoAdvantage

    No long-term contract; Paychex PEO sets the term in each order form or service agreement.

    Monthly4

  • Higher LeadChange Score

    G&A Partners

    7.3/10 in PEO Services vs 6.1 for Paychex PEO; Justworks (9.7), listed above for another reason, score higher still.

What should your next provider do better than Paychex PEO?

Your matches show verified evidence for it, never who pays us.

Paychex PEO alternatives, closest first

Products built for the same job come first, then products that also cover it, each group by similarity: the share of categories (50%), company sizes served (30%) and pricing model (20%) a product shares with Paychex PEO.

  1. ADP TotalSource

    vs Paychex PEO: ADP TotalSource: quote-only; Paychex PEO: quote-only. PEO Services score 5.7 vs 6.1.

    Similarity83 of 100
  2. Abel HR

    vs Paychex PEO: Abel HR: quote-only; Paychex PEO: quote-only. PEO Services score 4.8 vs 6.1.

    Similarity75 of 100
  3. DecisionHR

    vs Paychex PEO: DecisionHR: quote-only; Paychex PEO: quote-only. PEO Services score 4.5 vs 6.1.

    Similarity75 of 100
  4. Emplicity

    vs Paychex PEO: Emplicity: quote-only; Paychex PEO: quote-only. PEO Services score 2.8 vs 6.1.

    Similarity75 of 100
  5. Engage PEO

    vs Paychex PEO: Engage PEO: quote-only; Paychex PEO: quote-only. PEO Services score 5.6 vs 6.1.

    Similarity75 of 100
  6. ExtensisHR

    vs Paychex PEO: ExtensisHR: quote-only; Paychex PEO: quote-only. PEO Services score 6.2 vs 6.1.

    Similarity75 of 100
  7. FrankCrum

    vs Paychex PEO: FrankCrum: quote-only; Paychex PEO: quote-only. PEO Services score 4.5 vs 6.1.

    Similarity75 of 100
  8. Helpside

    vs Paychex PEO: Helpside: quote-only; Paychex PEO: quote-only. Not scored yet in PEO Services; Paychex PEO scores 6.1.

    Similarity75 of 100
  9. INFINITI HR

    vs Paychex PEO: INFINITI HR: quote-only; Paychex PEO: quote-only. PEO Services score 5.7 vs 6.1.

    Similarity75 of 100
  10. Questco

    vs Paychex PEO: Questco: quote-only; Paychex PEO: quote-only. PEO Services score 4.4 vs 6.1.

    Similarity75 of 100

Why buyers look beyond Paychex PEO

  1. Quote-only pricing

    The HR PEO package shows only 'Get Custom Pricing', and the billing basis is not stated.

  2. Fees beyond the quote

    The PEO terms allow extra fees, such as a W-2 fee for clients not active through December 31, a per-location payroll delivery fee with postage, and a late fee for injuries reported after 48 hours.

  3. Custom term with early termination fee

    Leaving before the end of the term triggers an early termination fee based on the employee count times a daily amount set in the agreement.

Paychex PEO vs its closest alternatives

PEO Services comparison: LeadChange Score, pricing and verified service facts
ProductScorePublished priceIRS-certified PEO6ESAC accredited7,12Workers’ comp includedPricing modelStates served
Paychex PEO5,86.1Quote onlyYesYesYesQuote onlyNot published
ADP TotalSource9,105.7Quote onlyYesYesYesQuote onlyAll 50 states
Abel HR11,13,144.8Quote onlyYesNoYesQuote onlyLocations in New Jersey, New York, Florida and California; clients across the U.S.
DecisionHR15–174.5Quote onlyYesNoYesQuote onlyAll 50 states
Emplicity18,192.8Quote onlyNoNoYesQuote onlyNot published
Engage PEO20–225.6Quote onlyYesYesYesQuote onlyAll 50 states
ExtensisHR23,246.2Quote onlyYesYesYesQuote onlyAll 50 states, the U.S. Virgin Islands and Puerto Rico
FrankCrum254.5Quote onlyNoNoYesQuote onlyNot published

Alternatives to similar products

Frequently asked questions

What are the best alternatives to Paychex PEO?

Among products built for the same job in PEO Services, the closest to Paychex PEO are ADP TotalSource (83% similar), Abel HR (75% similar), and DecisionHR (75% similar), by the categories, company sizes and pricing model they share. ADP TotalSource vs Paychex PEO: ADP TotalSource: quote-only; Paychex PEO: quote-only. PEO Services score 5.7 vs 6.1.

Which PEO alternative to Paychex PEO has the lowest published price?

Justworks: From $1,975 a month at 25 employees (starting price); Paychex PEO does not publish comparable prices.

Which Paychex PEO alternatives publish their prices?

Of the alternatives to Paychex PEO, CoAdvantage, G&A Partners, Justworks, and Deel publish list prices for at least one plan. Paychex PEO prices by quote.

Which Paychex PEO alternative scores highest?

Justworks scores highest at 9.7/10; Paychex PEO scores 6.1. Closest to Paychex PEO: ADP TotalSource (83% similar, 5.7).

Why do teams look for Paychex PEO alternatives?

The fit limits documented for Paychex PEO: quote-only pricing, fees beyond the quote, and custom term with early termination fee. The “Why buyers look beyond Paychex PEO” section explains each one from its source.

Which Paychex PEO alternatives are IRS-certified PEOs?

Of the alternatives to Paychex PEO, ADP TotalSource (since 2017), DecisionHR (since 2017), Engage PEO (since 2017), ExtensisHR (since 2017), and 7 more are on the IRS public list of certified professional employer organizations (CPEOs), as Paychex PEO has been since January 1, 2017.

Which Paychex PEO alternatives include workers’ compensation?

ADP TotalSource, Abel HR, DecisionHR, Emplicity, and 10 more handle workers’ compensation as part of their service, as Paychex PEO does.

Is Justworks better than Paychex PEO?

Justworks scores 9.7/10 in PEO Services against 6.1 for Paychex PEO; which fits better depends on your headcount, budget and the modules you need. Feature by feature: Paychex PEO vs Justworks.

How this page was made

  • What it is built from

    70 verified facts, each checked against the vendor's own pages or another primary source, most recently on Nov 17, 2026.

  • Method

    Scored and compared with the LeadChange methodology, version 1.5. Read the methodology

  • Independent review

    Not reviewed yet by our independent reviewer. How we review

  • Hands-on testing

    We have not tested Paychex PEO hands-on: this page uses public information only.

  • Who made it

    The LeadChange Research Team, following a written research process. No named expert has reviewed this page. About us

  • Independence and errors

    Who pays us never changes a score or a rank. If something here is wrong, tell us and we correct it publicly. Request a correction

Switching from Paychex PEO?

Tell us why you’re leaving and when your contract ends, and see the alternatives that fit, with verified evidence for what you need, ranked without regard to who pays us.

Sources

The 33 pages this page's facts come from. The date beside each is our last check of the facts taken from it (the oldest, when they differ). The numbers beside the figures above link here.

Quotes from the sources
  1. Justworks justworks.com/pricing“Justworks PEO pricing starts at $79 per month per employee for our Basic plan and $124 per month per employee for our Plus plan. Justworks Payroll customers pay $8 per month per employee plus a $50 base fee.” “Transparent & Simple Pricing”
  2. Deel deel.com/pricing“Transparent and fair pricing that grows with your business”
  3. Amplify HR Management amplifyhr.com“Core PEO Services PEO Overview PEO for Small Businesses PEO for Middle Market PEO for Enterprise”
  4. CoAd coad.com/pricing“Base and Pro are month-to-month with no cancellation fees — you can leave anytime. Custom arrangements are discussed during onboarding and may involve a minimum term. PEO agreements are typically structured on an annual basis given the depth of the co-employment relationship.” “Named advisor or co-employer. You focus on the business. We manage HR operations — end to end.”
  5. Paychex paychex.com/human-resources/hr-packages“Get Custom Pricing”
  6. Internal Revenue Service irs.gov/pub/irs-sbse/active-cpeos.pdf“Paychex PEO VI LLC 970 Lake Carillon Drive Suite 400 ST. PETERSB URG FL 33716 US 1/1/2017” “ADP TotalSource, Inc 10200 Sunset Drive MIAMI FL 33173 US 1/1/2017”
  7. Employer Services Assurance Corporation (ESAC) findapeo.esac.org/findpeo.aspx?S=US-TX“Paychex” “ADP TotalSource, Inc.”
  8. Paychex Paychex: PEO services“Included and managed by PEO”
  9. ADP adp.com/solutions/employer-services/totalsource.aspx“ADP TotalSource pricing is quoted rather than listed, since it is built around factors that are specific to your business” “Pay your employees accurately and on time across one state or all 50, with all-in-one payroll and tax support handled by ADP specialists”
  10. ADP apps.adp.com/en-us/apps/234948/adp-totalsource---a-peo-solution/features“Your ADP workers’ compensation claims specialist is your resource for any questions related to workers’ compensation and will handle the end-to-end claims process”
  11. Abel HR abelhr.com/contact-us“Now that you have found Abel HR, call or email us today to get started!” “New Jersey, New York, Florida, and California.”
  12. Employer Services Assurance Corporation (ESAC) esac.org/Business/find-a-peo“Select a state from the below map or drop-down menu for a list of accredited PEOs prepared to serve you and your employees in your area”
  13. Abel HR abelhr.com/services/safety-workers-compensation“Best of all, with Abel’s volume plan for workers’ compensation insurance, you pay a consistent monthly premium with no large deposits or surprises at the end of the year.”
  14. Abel HR abelhr.com/free-quote“I am new to Abel HR”
  15. DecisionHR decisionhr.com/contact“You’ll just need to provide us with basic information on your company.” “It is very easy to get a quote from DecisionHR!”
  16. DecisionHR decisionhr.com“Outstanding risk management services inclusive of Workers’ Compensation Insurance and Employment Practices Liability Insurance (EPLI).”
  17. DecisionHR decisionhr.com/your-team“We’re excited to share that we now support all 50 states in the USA.”
  18. Emplicity emplicity.com/about“We’ve streamlined the process and made it simple to get the details you need.”
  19. Emplicity emplicity.com/services“Fully insured workers’ compensation carrier with “AAA” rated national carrier Multi-state coverage Expert claims management and loss control” “Customized Plans. Transparent Fees. Dedicated Team.”
  20. Engage PEO engagepeo.com“Our tailored PEO services streamline operations while ensuring accuracy, compliance, and efficiency”
  21. Engage PEO engagepeo.com/services/risk-solutions“Protect your employees and stay compliant with workers’ compensation insurance, covering medical expenses and lost wages for work-related injuries.”
  22. Engage PEO engagepeo.com/about“with Engage now serving clients in all 50 states”
  23. ExtensisHR extensishr.com/contact“Fill out the form and a member of our team will be in touch.” “Contact us for a personalized quote.”
  24. ExtensisHR extensishr.com/services/peo“Workers’ compensation insurance”
  25. FrankCrum frankcrum.com/pricing“We'd rather give you an accurate quote than a misleading estimate.” “Workers' comp insurance and claims management”
  26. G&A Partners gnapartners.com/peo“A typical range for PEO services with G&A Partners is $65-150 per month per employee for core HR functions. Employer-paid benefits costs are often a separate line item.” “Risk management and safety services, including workers’ compensation and claims assistance”
  27. Deel deel.com/solutions/hr“Core starts at $5 per employee per month and covers worker profiles, org chart, time off, job architecture, workflows, approvals, anonymous reporting, and people analytics.”
  28. Helpside helpside.com/risk-management“Qualifying Helpside clients have access to a unique workers’ compensation plan that offers:”
  29. INFINITI HR infinitihr.com/resources/faqs“Employer Mandatory Insurance True-Group Workers’ Compensation and EPLI”
  30. Questco questco.net/hr-services/safety-workers-compensation“Access to WC insurance at attractive rates”
  31. Amplify HR Management amplifyhr.com/faqs“Yes. We offer comprehensive workers’ compensation coverage and claims management services.”
  32. Justworks help.justworks.com/hc/en-us/articles/360004473472-Workers-Compensation-Insurance“Once you sign up with Justworks PEO, you and your employees will be covered under the Justworks workers compensation policies, with some exceptions..”
  33. Deel help.letsdeel.com/hc/en-gb/articles/26543769986833-PEO-Responsibilities-and-Client-Responsibilities“Provide Workers’ Compensation Insurance coverage for covered employees and administer claims under said coverage in accordance with applicable law.”

Vendor? Reach buyers comparing Paychex PEO