Independent research on 287 HR & workforce products. Facts checked against vendors’ official documentation.

We may earn a referral fee. We may earn a referral feeHow we make money

Square Payroll

Best Square Payroll Alternatives

10 products that do the same job as Square Payroll, matched to the reason you might switch, with similarity scores and published prices.

By LeadChange Research TeamUpdated Based on 33 sources, most recently checked

LeadChange may earn a fee when you request pricing through our site, or a commission through a partner link. Rankings never depend on whether a vendor pays us.We may earn a fee.

Square Payroll alternatives, closest first

  1. Patriot PayrollSimilarity 83
  2. SurePayrollSimilarity 75
  3. GustoSimilarity 70

Alternatives by reason for switching

  • Lower published price

    Patriot Payroll

    $162 a month at 25 employees vs $185 for Square Payroll.

    $37/mo + $5/employee/mo (Full Service Payroll plan)1

  • Built for larger companies

    Paycor

    Serves enterprise companies; Square Payroll does not list enterprise among the sizes it serves.

    Small businesses, mid-market companies, enterprises2

  • Built for mid-sized companies

    QuickBooks Payroll

    Serves mid-sized companies; Square Payroll does not list them among the sizes it serves.

    Small businesses, mid-market companies3

  • Higher LeadChange Score

    Gusto

    8.1/10 in Payroll Software vs 7.7 for Square Payroll; Patriot Payroll (8.7) and QuickBooks Payroll (8.5), listed above for another reason, score higher still.

What should your next provider do better than Square Payroll?

Your matches show verified evidence for it, never who pays us.

Square Payroll alternatives, closest first

Products built for the same job come first, then products that also cover it, each group by similarity: the share of categories (50%), company sizes served (30%) and pricing model (20%) a product shares with Square Payroll.

  1. Patriot Payroll

    vs Square Payroll: From $162 vs $185 a month at 25 employees (starting prices). Payroll Software score 8.7 vs 7.7.

    Similarity83 of 100

    From $37/mo + $5/employee/mo (Full Service Payroll plan)1

  2. SurePayroll

    vs Square Payroll: From $204 vs $185 a month at 25 employees (starting prices). Payroll Software score 4.9 vs 7.7.

    Similarity75 of 100

    From $29/mo + $7/employee/mo (Full Service plan)4

  3. Gusto

    vs Square Payroll: From $199 vs $185 a month at 25 employees (starting prices). Payroll Software score 8.1 vs 7.7.

    Similarity70 of 100

    From $49/mo + $6/employee/mo5

  4. Wave Payroll

    vs Square Payroll: From $190 vs $185 a month at 25 employees (starting prices). Not scored yet in Payroll Software; Square Payroll scores 7.7.

    Similarity67 of 100

    From $40/mo + $6/employee/mo6

  5. Paychex Flex

    vs Square Payroll: Paychex Flex: from $39/mo + $5/employee; Square Payroll: from $35/mo + $6/employee. Payroll Software score 7.2 vs 7.7.

    Similarity60 of 100

    From $39/mo + $5/employee/mo (up to 19 employees)7

  6. QuickBooks Payroll

    vs Square Payroll: From $225 vs $185 a month at 25 employees (starting prices). Payroll Software score 8.5 vs 7.7.

    Similarity60 of 100

    From $50/mo + $7/employee/mo8

  7. ADP RUN Powered by ADP

    vs Square Payroll: ADP RUN Powered by ADP: quote-only; Square Payroll: from $35/mo + $6/employee. Payroll Software score 5.1 vs 7.7.

    Similarity55 of 100
  8. OnPay

    vs Square Payroll: From $199 vs $185 a month at 25 employees (starting prices). Payroll Software score 7.6 vs 7.7.

    Similarity55 of 100

    From $49/mo + $6/employee/mo (Payroll Essentials plan)9

  9. Paycor

    vs Square Payroll: Paycor: quote-only; Square Payroll: from $35/mo + $6/employee. Payroll Software score 6.3 vs 7.7.

    Similarity22 of 100
  10. Netchex

    vs Square Payroll: Netchex: quote-only; Square Payroll: from $35/mo + $6/employee. Payroll Software score 4.8 vs 7.7.

    Similarity21 of 100

Why buyers look beyond Square Payroll

  1. Benefits come from partners and cost extra

    Health insurance runs through SimplyInsured, the employer pays at least 50% of premiums, and it is not offered in HI, MN, ND, SD, VT or DC. Vestwell's most popular 401(k) plan costs $125 a month plus $8 per participant.

  2. Limits on multi-jurisdiction payroll

    Square does not support one employee who works in more than one tax jurisdiction, courtesy withholding, or several EINs in one payroll account.

  3. Not for every employer type

    Square Payroll is only for businesses that file Form 941 or Form 944. It does not support household or agricultural employees.

  4. Some services are paid extras

    Mailing paper W-2s and 1099s costs $3 per form each year. Fixing past tax forms is a paid service quoted per case, and workers' comp is a separate policy from NEXT Insurance.

  5. Weekday specialist hours

    Payroll specialists answer Monday to Friday, 6 a.m. to 6 p.m. Pacific time.

Square Payroll vs its closest alternatives

Payroll Software comparison: LeadChange Score, pricing and verified features
ProductScoreStarting price per employeeStarting base feePricing modelFree trialAPIMobile apps
Square Payroll107.7$6/employee/mo$35/moBase fee + per employeeNot verifiedNot verifiedSquare Team App
Patriot Payroll18.7$5/employee/mo$37/moBase fee + per employeeYesNot verifiedMobile web (no app to install)
SurePayroll4,114.9$7/employee/mo$29/moBase fee + per employeeNoNot verifiedYes
Gusto5,12,138.1$6/employee/mo$49/moBase fee + per employeeNoYesiOS (Gusto Mobile), Android (Gusto Mobile)
Wave Payroll6,14Not scored$6/employee/mo$40/moBase fee + per employeeYesNot verifiedWeb browser only (payroll is not in the Wave mobile app)
Paychex Flex7,15,167.2$5/employee/mo (under 20 employees)$39/mo (under 20 employees)Base fee + per employeeNot verifiedYesPaychex Flex app (iOS), Paychex Flex app (Android), Paychex Flex Time Kiosk app
QuickBooks Payroll8,17–198.5$7/employee/mo$50/moBase fee + per employeeYesNoiOS (QuickBooks Workforce), Android (QuickBooks Workforce)
ADP RUN Powered by ADP20–225.1Not verifiedNot verifiedQuote onlyNoYesRUN Powered by ADP app (iOS), RUN Powered by ADP app (Android)

Not verified = we have no sourced value for it yet.

Alternatives to similar products

Frequently asked questions

What are the best alternatives to Square Payroll?

Among products built for the same job in Payroll Software, the closest to Square Payroll are Patriot Payroll (83% similar), SurePayroll (75% similar), and Gusto (70% similar), by the categories, company sizes and pricing model they share. Patriot Payroll vs Square Payroll: From $162 vs $185 a month at 25 employees (starting prices). Payroll Software score 8.7 vs 7.7.

What is a cheaper alternative to Square Payroll?

Patriot Payroll: From $162 a month at 25 employees vs $185 for Square Payroll (starting prices).

Which Square Payroll alternatives publish their prices?

Of the alternatives to Square Payroll, Patriot Payroll, SurePayroll, Gusto, Wave Payroll, Paychex Flex, QuickBooks Payroll, and OnPay publish list prices for at least one plan. Square Payroll publishes its prices too.

Which Square Payroll alternative scores highest?

Patriot Payroll scores highest at 8.7/10, 83% similar to Square Payroll; Square Payroll scores 7.7.

Why do teams look for Square Payroll alternatives?

The fit limits documented for Square Payroll: benefits come from partners and cost extra, you send garnishment payments yourself, and limits on multi-jurisdiction payroll. The “Why buyers look beyond Square Payroll” section explains each one from its source.

Which Square Payroll alternatives integrate with QuickBooks Online?

Patriot Payroll, Gusto, Paychex Flex, QuickBooks Payroll, and 4 more document an integration with QuickBooks Online, like Square Payroll.

Which Square Payroll alternatives offer a free trial?

Of the alternatives to Square Payroll, Patriot Payroll, Wave Payroll, QuickBooks Payroll, and OnPay list a free trial.

Is QuickBooks Payroll better than Square Payroll?

QuickBooks Payroll scores 8.5/10 in Payroll Software against 7.7 for Square Payroll; which fits better depends on your headcount, budget and the modules you need. Feature by feature: Square Payroll vs QuickBooks Payroll.

How this page was made

  • What it is built from

    56 verified facts, each checked against the vendor's own pages or another primary source, most recently on Nov 17, 2026.

  • Method

    Scored and compared with the LeadChange methodology, version 1.5. Read the methodology

  • Independent review

    Our independent review of Nov 4, 2026 asked for changes. How we review

  • Hands-on testing

    We have not tested Square Payroll hands-on: this page uses public information only.

  • Who made it

    The LeadChange Research Team, following a written research process. No named expert has reviewed this page. About us

  • Independence and errors

    Who pays us never changes a score or a rank. If something here is wrong, tell us and we correct it publicly. Request a correction

Switching from Square Payroll?

Tell us why you’re leaving and when your contract ends, and see the alternatives that fit, with verified evidence for what you need, ranked without regard to who pays us.

Sources

The 33 pages this page's facts come from. The date beside each is our last check of the facts taken from it (the oldest, when they differ). The numbers beside the figures above link here.

Quotes from the sources
  1. Patriot Software patriotsoftware.com/pricing“Basic Payroll is $17/month + $4 per worker paid; Full Service Payroll is $37/month + $5 per worker paid.” “Our payroll is a flat monthly fee + per worker paid fee. Run as many payrolls as you need. We'll bill you in arrears each month.”
  2. Paycor paycor.com/plans-pricing“50-1000 EMPLOYEES”
  3. Intuit quickbooks.intuit.com/payroll“QuickBooks Workforce works for small to midsize businesses—from accountants and financial experts to hospitality companies, construction companies, truckers, and more.”
  4. SurePayroll (Paychex) surepayroll.com/payroll“Pay employees in minutes, easily access reports, and get payroll taxes filed and deposited automatically.” “Billed monthly. Cancel anytime.”
  5. Gusto gusto.com/product/pricing“Simple Run basic payroll in one state. $49/mo + $6/mo per person” “Simple, transparent pricing Payroll, benefits, and HR all in one place. No hidden fees. Cancel any time.”
  6. Wave waveapps.com/payroll“$40 USD base fee+ $6 per active employee+ $6 per independent contractor paid” “Upon processing your first payroll, you can use Wave Payroll for up to 30 days, commitment-free. At any time, you can activate to start your billing cycle and gain access to items like tax filing and approving payrolls beyond the current month.”
  7. Paychex paychex.com/payroll/paychex-flex-essentials“Our most affordable option: Only $39/mo. + $5 per employee … Rest easy knowing your federal, state, and identified local payroll taxes will be calculated, paid, and filed on your behalf. *Additional fees may apply. … Get your required employee and independent contractor tax forms for tax season. **Available at additional cost.”
  8. Intuit quickbooks.intuit.com/payroll/pricing/bundle“WORKFORCE PAYROLL Pay your team and get payroll taxes done for you. $50 + $7/employee” “Find the right payroll plan for you”
  9. OnPay onpay.com/payroll/software/costs-pricing“Payroll Essentials $49 base + $6/worker per month” “Transparent pricing. Scalable solutions.”
  10. Square squareup.com/us/en/payroll/pricing“For full-service payroll, the cost is $35 per month, plus $6 per person paid per month. For contractor-only payroll, the cost is $6 per person paid per month.” “Manage your team and run payroll anytime, from anywhere, with the Square Team App.”
  11. SurePayroll (Paychex) surepayroll.com/pricing“During your first 12 months with SurePayroll, every alternating month will be free.” “Mobile app for employers and employees”
  12. Gusto Payroll (Gusto)“We’ve got all kinds of plans for all sizes of business. Explore all the options. You’ll pay nothing ‘til you’re ready to run payroll.” “Yes, you can run payroll, check payroll status, add and view team members and manage your team all from the Gusto mobile app. Download the iOS app here and the Google Play app here.”
  13. Gusto docs.gusto.com“Leverage Gusto's API to build your own in-app payroll solution, customized for your users' needs, with Gusto Embedded.”
  14. Wave support.waveapps.com/hc/en-us/articles/360030007911-Understand-Wave-s-payroll-subscription“Wave’s payroll feature is only available on web browsers.”
  15. Paychex paychex.com/integrations“Plus, Paychex APIs and developer resources make building applications, connections, and solution integrations easier than ever.”
  16. Paychex paychex.com/apps/mobile-app“Employees can download the Paychex Flex® app for free from the Apple App Store or Google Play Store and log in using their Paychex account credentials.”
  17. Intuit quickbooks.intuit.com/payroll/one-employee“Free trial applies to the monthly base price for the first thirty (30) days of new subscriptions to QuickBooks Online and/or Workforce.”
  18. Intuit developer.intuit.com/app/developer/payroll-time/docs/faq“For the rest of the Workforce APIs, access to this data is currently restricted to approved partners only. To request access, open a support ticket.”
  19. Intuit quickbooks.intuit.com/time-tracking/mobile“QuickBooks Workforce is also available in the Apple App Store and Google Play Store.”
  20. ADP adp.com/what-we-offer/payroll/payroll-for-1-49-employees/payroll-packages.aspx“Payroll costs are influenced by several variables, including how often you run payroll, the number of employees or contractors you pay and how frequently your workforce changes. Pricing may also increase if you add HR tools, benefits administration or more advanced compliance support, such as garnishment management or State Unemployment Insurance.” “Switch your payroll & HR before November 26th and get up to 6 months FREE!* *See terms & conditions Get Pricing Small Business Payroll Overview Payroll Packages Switching to ADP Payroll for One See our self-led demo to see how easy payroll and HR can be.”
  21. ADP marketplace-cdn.adp.com/dev-portal/pdf/protected/RUN_Powered_by_ADP_API_Catalog“The Marketplace API Catalog for RUN Powered By ADP lists APIs supported by RUN Powered By ADP”
  22. ADP (Apple App Store listing) apps.apple.com/us/app/adp-run/id388928133“the RUN Powered by ADP® payroll mobile app is built for the way your small business works. Here are some of the features available at your fingertips—wherever your day takes you. • Start payroll with a tap • Avoid payroll mistakes with error detection powered by AI”
  23. Paychex paychex.com/payroll/compare-payroll-solutions“Basic Essential Payroll & HR Request Pricing Foundations AI & HR Features Best Value Request Pricing Advanced Enhanced Service Needs Request Pricing Complete Premium Services Request Pricing”
  24. Square squareup.com/us/en/payroll/small-business“Transparent pricing with no hidden fees or long-term commitments.”
  25. OnPay onpay.com“Get one month free”
  26. Square squareup.com/help/us/en/article/6299-sync-square-payroll-with-quickbooks-online
  27. Patriot Software patriotsoftware.com/payroll
  28. Gusto gusto.com/product
  29. Paychex pages.paychex.com/intuit.html
  30. ADP support.adp.com/adp_payroll/content/hybrid/GL/RUN_GL_Guide_QBO.pdf
  31. OnPay onpay.com/app-directory
  32. Paycor marketplace.paycor.com/en-US/apps/462836/quickbooks
  33. Netchex netchex.com/quickbooks

Vendor? Reach buyers comparing Square Payroll